Not a member? Sign up

Building a new J-school? Build the newsroom first

by: Lisa Williams |

Not too long ago, I visited Gainesville, Florida, home of the University of Florida/Gainesville, where I participated in Journalism/Interactive. The main focus of this organization?  Reforming, and reinventing journalism education.  

Journalism education is at a crossroads: As tuition continues to rise while employment in the field has taken a terrifying nosedive in the last five years, many people feel that journalism education hasn't changed fast enough to give graduates a shot at entering, and staying in, their chosen profession.  Surveying 1900+ professionals, Poynter found that more than half felt that journalism education wasn't keeping pace with changes in the industry.

VIDEO:  "Creating the Journalist Coder," with Cindy Royal, University of Texas, Jeremy Gilbert, Medill School of Journalism, Northwestern University, Mike Foley, University of Florida, and me, Lisa Williams:  

When I listened to instructors from schools across the country at Journalism Interactive, what I heard was that for many of them, getting to consensus about changing a curriculum that took decades to build was a real slog. Journalists with decades of experience and Ph.D.s with serious scholarly work were, understandably, less than eager to do things that felt like giving up on, or minimizing the importance of, skills and knowledge they'd spent a lifetime acquiring to replace them with classes about entrepreneurship, programming, or data visualization. 

"What would you do if you could start from scratch?" I asked one journalism educator. Seeing the pained expression on their face, I was immediately sorry I'd asked - it's not like they had the freedom to redesign their school from scratch.  

I'll admit, I thought of the "start from scratch" question as entirely hypothetical, but there is, in fact, one School of Communications in the US that IS starting from scratch.  As surprising as it is to find that any university is starting a school of communications today, that's exactly what Montclair State University is doing. 

And Montclair State - part of New Jersey's public higher education system - is doing something really interesting: they're building the newsroom first.  

Michelle Johnson of Boston University talks about bringing real-world newsrooms into collaboration with j-schools as "a teaching-hospital model of journalism education."  Usually, this means partnerships with local news organizations, along with an apprenticeship or internship program, or in BU's case, students run a news bureau with the goal of producing output of high enough quality to be picked up by their area's print, radio, and television broadcast outlets.  

But in Montclair State's case, the strategy isn't "outbound" - the school isn't sending out students or clips to news organizations. The school is bringing news organizations in - hosting news organizations right on campus. No less than eight newsrooms will have a presence at the university's Center for Cooperative Media:  

  • AOL/Patch New Jersey;
  • NJ.com, which includes the online presence of the Newark Star-Ledger, New Jersey's largest paper by circulation, and the Trenton Times, the daily paper of the state's capital;
  • North Jersey Media Group, which publishes several papers including the Bergen County Record;
  • NJ Spotlight, an award-winning watchdog news site;
  • Reuters
  • WBGO, an NPR affiliate;
  • NJPR, a series of four New Jersey stations run by NPR affiliate WNYC, as part of WNYC's effort to expand news coverage of New Jersey;
  • NJTV -- NJTV's 25-person newsroom will be housed at the Center, and the network's nightly news program NJToday will be broadcast live from the campus

The Center will also be the host to the NJ News Commons, which was the Center's first funded project.  The NJ News Commons, a Knight Community Information Challenge winner, will provide training opportunities, host public conversations and conferences, and promote collaborative news projects.  

"We're building a bricks-and-mortar home for the major media organizations in the state," says Matthew Frankel of Montclair State, "a place where NJTV can walk down the hall and bump into NJ Spotlight -- one of the most important policy-oriented sites in the state -- and collaborate on something." 

In an era where there's so much focus on the virtual, Montclair State's new initiative is focused on real-world interaction: "The second thing that this hub is going to provide is bricks and mortar for these entitities that may not necessarily have office space and give them a situation where they have a phone, internet, and conference rooms, as well as an HD studio and radio studio at their disposal.  So the idea is (in part) to take these things that the university has and leveraging them so that media organizations aren't focused on finding money for these things and instead spend that effort on newsgathering."  

The fact that news organizations have a presence on campus offers a unique opportunity for students, Frankel says.  "I'm a product of internships," says Frankel. "I went to school in Ohio but I got to go to Washington DC to intern.  Our students are getting really interesting, valuable, on-campus opportunities -- and we hope the students will be really valuable to [the news organizations] as well."  

This blog is made possible by a grant from the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Lisa Williams

Lisa Williams is the Director of Digital Engagement for the Investigative News Network. She is also CEO and founder of Placeblogger.com,
Read More

Events
Submit an event

Philanthropy Southwest Annual Conference November 6-8

November 6, 2014 - November 8, 2014

Philanthropy Southwest’s Annual Conference, this year in Phoenix, Ariz.,  consistently draws several hundred trustees and staff attendees from grantmaking organizations of all types and sizes. https://www.philanthropysouthwest.org/annual-conference-0

American Library Association Midwinter Meeting

January 30, 2015 - February 3, 2015

Registration is now open for the ALA meeting, which will be held in Chicago.

Nonprofit Technology Conference

March 4, 2015 - March 6, 2015

The NTC is the nonprofit industry's signature technology event, bringing together more than 2,000 nonprofit staff, vendors, and consultants. 

2015 Computer-Assisted Reporting Conference, March 5-8

March 5, 2015

Join IRE and NICAR in Atlanta for our annual conference devoted to data journalism, March 5-8, 2015 at the Atlanta Marriott Marquis. Come and learn about tools you need to dig deeper into stories and give readers, viewers and your online audience the information they're demanding.

Sunshine Week: Your Right to Know

March 15, 2015 - March 21, 2015

Launched in 2005, Sunshine Week has grown into an enduring annual initiative to promote open government and push back against excessive official secrecy.  

2015 Philanthropy Southwest Spring Summit

April 19, 2015 - April 22, 2015

Save the Date! Philanthropy Southwest's 2015 Spring Conference will be held at the AT & T Executive Education and Conference Center, The University of Texas in Austin, Texas! Check back here for additional details as they become available.

Summer 2015 Journalism Ethnics Fellowship

May 24, 2015

The May 24-June 7, 2015 program is sponsored by Fellowships at Auschwitz for the Study of Professional Ethics in collaboration with The Museum of Jewish Heritage—A Living Memorial to the Holocaust. Applications are being accepting for a fellowship, which uses the conduct of journalists during the Holocaust and in Nazi Germany as a launching point for an intensive two-week summer program on contemporary journalism ethics.

IRE 2015 Annual Conference, June 4-7

June 4, 2015

The Investigative Reporters & Editors annual conference in Philadelphia attracts the best in the business and offers more than 150 panels, hands-on classes and special presentations about covering business, public safety, government, health care, education, the military, the environment and other key beats.

Allied Media 2015 Annual Conference, June 18-21

June 18, 2015

Save the date for the 17th annual Allied Media Conference, June 18-21, 2015 in Detroit.

Philanthropy Southwest 2015 Annual conference

October 22, 2015

Save the Date! Philanthropy Southwest's 67th Annual Conference will be held in Santa Fe, New Mexico.

Submit an event

A breakdown of the Publishers' Toolbox from Knight Lab

By Melissa Kaplan
10/7/2014 | 9:25 pm GMT

Knight Project Lab's Publishers' Toolbox offers five different, swift assets for telling multimedia stories. A site editor can access the...

Comment platforms: How to choose one for your news site

By Melissa Kaplan
9/23/2014 | 4:49 pm GMT

Audience engagement is vital to keeping any community news site alive and well, and comments on stories are an immediate...