Not a member? Sign up

Local independent news operations demonstrate staying power

by: Michele McLellan |

When I first started studying an emergent group of local online news startups in 2009, it was because I was skeptical of a narrative that went something like this: Newspapers had to be saved because the only alternative was angry bloggers who couldn’t be trusted with the facts.

As a few years passed, the narrative changed, but not for the better. The slow-motion train wreck of Patch became the dominant story, often obscuring real progress on the part of independent local news startups.

But there are indications that a new, more optimistic narrative is emerging.

For one thing, the startups are demonstrating staying power.

I have been tracking local independent sites on my database, Michele’s List, since 2010, when I was a fellow at the Reynolds Journalism Institute. There are now 312 sites on the list – not the full universe of local start ups, but independent sites that meet specific criteria of producing journalism, engaging with users, and working on a revenue model.

This month, I took a look at the longevity of 287 sites for which I have the year of launch.

What I found was impressive: 60 percentof the sites are five years or older this year, with a handful dating back to the late 1990s post 2000. The remaining 40 percent launched between 2011 and 2014. 

Here are percentages the year of for launch and a few randome examples of sites, starting with those that launched prior to and in 2005 and then annually through last year:

<2005 12% Baristanet, Brownstoner, CTNewsJunkie, Gaper's Block, Voice of San Diego
  2006   4 Red Bank Green, Evanston Now, Popville, Twin Cities Daily Planet
  2007   6 The B-Town Blog, 30A, MinnPost, My Ballard, Noozhawk, Baltimore Brew
  2008   9 The Batavian, Q City Metro, EastsiderLA,, Hawaii Independent 
  2009 18 Berkeleyside, VT Digger, Corona Del Mar Today, The Rapidian, The Lens
  2010 11 Watershed Post, Riverhead Local, City Limits, ARLNow, Potomac Local
  2011   5 Yellowstone Gate, My Everett News, Planet Princeton, Genesee Sun
  2012 10 Motor City Muckraker, Investigative Post, The Brookhaven Post, Camel City Dispatch
  2013 11 Racine County Today, Benito Link, Mid-City Messenter, South Slope News
  2014 13 Billy Penn, Watertown News, Stillwater Current, The Berkshire Edge

As I have noted before, there are surges – one in 2009-2010 as newspaper newsrooms contracted and another in 2013-14 as Patch shed staff. I generally do not add sites that are less than a year old – I want to see first whether they have legs, especially on the revenue side – so there are not any sites that launched this year.

We have added about 30 sites to the list this year and further updates are under way, mostly sites that have been around for a while that we are just discovering. By contrast, we dropped nine sites this year; most had stopped publication but one was sold to a magazine and another merged with Hoodline, a San Francisco Bay area neighborhoods site that is on my "watch list" of relatively new sites. (Nine represents less than three percent attrition for the year.)

Other recent coverage validates the idea that local – of a certain scale – is a going concern:

  •  A recent post on Nieman Lab caught up with former Patch journalists who started their own local news sites after Patch imploded. As the post points out, Patch actually served as something of an incubator for their efforts because they received practical training that has served them well in their new roles.
  • Streetfight took a look at the TAPinto network of 46 sites that operates on a franchise model in New Jersey and New York. It is a local, ground-up approach to operating at a scale that can draw advertising. Local owners operate as franchisees while TAPinto provides the tech platform and sales expertise and training. With 46 sites in 60 communities, founder Michael Shapiro told Streetfight the company is profitable.
This good news doesn't mean local news startups are consistently profitable, or even have figured ot the business model. For one thing, high dependence on display advertising is a vulnerability for the majority of these sites.
However, Matt DeRienzo, interim esecutive director of LION Publishers, with a membership of about 130 publishers, pointed to another promising development: Some publishers have started to reduce their reliance on traditional display advertising.
DeRienzo noted that Local News Now in the Washington, D.C. area, has developed several native advertising products, and San Angelo Live in Texas, sells advertising against a six-day-a-week has e-newsletter. As well, The Lo-Down in New York City conducted a successful crowd-funding campaign for a reporting project and Berkeleyside in California derives 20 percent of its revenue from membership.
“I think the engagement around crowdfunding (if done carefully and not over-done) and definitely around membership can/will lead to other revenue success as well,” DiRienzo said in an e-mail. “It shows advertisers and sponsors and foundations how vital a site is to the community.”

Note: Here is a post I wrote about revenue diversification ideas shared at the LION Summit in October. 

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Michele McLellan

Michele McLellan is a writer, editor and consultant who works on projects that help strengthen the emerging local news ecosystem,
Read More

Submit an event

Media that Matters: Story, Money, Impact

Wed, June 1, 2016 5:00 pm - Sun, June 5, 2016 2:00 pm

Media That Matters: Story Money Impact is a practical workshop for media-makers, principled funders, and highly motivated activists who want to ensure their work makes an undeniable difference.  This intimate conference illuminates the spark of engagement at the core of these three pursuits. Structured around case studies from the front lines, Story Money Impact reveals best practices in the areas of documentary, digital content, and independent journalism. 

[email protected] Conference

Thu, June 2, 2016 9:00 am - Sat, June 4, 2016 2:00 pm

[email protected] is a three-day gathering tied to the 50th anniversary of the Freedom of Information Act. The conference will explore FOIA’s origins, importance, and its role in American law, politics and society. [email protected] is co-sponsored by the Dart Center for Journalism and Trauma.

Marketing Analytics & Data Science 2016

Wed, June 8, 2016 8:00 am - Fri, June 10, 2016 3:30 pm

The conference is designed to help you navigate an age where consumers demand more personalized communications, experiences and products, and internal stakeholders require more predictive intelligence to inform decisions, analytics and data science have emerged as silver bullets to uncover the human side of data.

Social Media Weekend 2016

Fri, June 10, 2016 9:00 am - Sat, June 11, 2016 6:00 pm

At the Social Media Weekend catch up on the latest social media trends, tools and people with @Sree Sreenivasan and friends at CUNY J-School. This June's #smwknd will offer two very full days of insights and networking, Q&As with social stars, Sree's State of Social presentation, free consultations with Social Media doctors, and more.

Investigative Reporters & Editors Conference

Thu, June 16, 2016 9:00 am - Sun, June 19, 2016 12:30 pm

The best in the business will gather for the Investigative Reporters & Editors Conference for more than 150 panels, hands-on classes and special presentations about covering business, public safety, government, health care, education, the military, the environment and other key beats. Speakers will share strategies for locating documents and gaining access to public records, finding the best stories and managing investigations. Join the discussion about how to practice investigative journalism in print, broadcast, Web and alternative newsroom models. 

Submit an event

The demographics of social media news consumers

By Nancy Yoshihara
5/30/2016 | 10:00 pm GMT

The five social networking sites with the biggest news audiences appeal to somewhat different groups, according to a new report...

Tools that help reporters with routine tasks

By Nancy Yoshihara
5/22/2016 | 10:00 pm GMT

Digging up leads, tracking developments and transcribing interviews are all made easier with five tools that Rob Tornoe at Editor...